Does Running a Lottery Serve the Public Interest?

A lottery is a game in which participants pay for a ticket or group of tickets, then select one or more numbers to win prizes. Some states run lotteries for a wide range of items, from units in subsidized housing blocks to kindergarten placements. Others focus primarily on cash prizes. Because lotteries are run as businesses with a primary aim of maximizing revenues, their advertising necessarily focuses on persuading target groups to spend their money on the lottery. This raises the question: Does running a state-sponsored gambling operation serve the public interest?

The prevailing argument for state-sponsored lotteries is that they provide “painless” revenue, which is viewed by both voters and politicians as a way to raise money without having to increase taxes or cut other public spending. This is a powerful argument in times of economic stress, as it can be used to justify government spending even when the public is skeptical about its necessity. However, the popularity of lotteries does not appear to be linked to a state’s objective fiscal health; studies show that it is equally popular in prosperous times as in periods of financial stress.

People buy lottery tickets based on the belief that they can make their lives better if they win. This is a form of covetousness, which the Bible forbids (Exodus 20:17; Ecclesiastes 5:10). Although winning the lottery can lead to good fortune, most players find that the happiness they experience quickly dissipates when their winnings are gone. The ephemeral nature of winnings also makes it difficult for them to build permanent wealth.

The first recorded lotteries were held in the Low Countries in the 15th century to raise funds for town fortifications and to help the poor. By the 18th century, public lotteries were widespread in England and the American colonies, where they helped fund the establishment of Harvard and Yale, among other colleges. Benjamin Franklin sponsored a lottery to raise funds for cannons during the Revolution, and George Washington attempted to use a lottery to finance his road project across the Blue Ridge Mountains.

State-sponsored lotteries also appeal to specific constituencies, including convenience store owners and their suppliers; teachers in states where some of the proceeds are earmarked for education; and state legislators, who quickly become accustomed to the extra revenue. They also generate substantial revenues for advertising agencies and other vendors that promote the lottery.

There is a growing body of research that suggests that the odds of winning are much lower than advertised. Some of the key reasons are that lottery tickets are sold with hidden costs, such as commissions to dealers; a lack of transparency in the distribution of prizes; and the tendency for lotteries to become increasingly homogenous in terms of demographic characteristics. The results of these studies indicate that there are ways to improve the efficiency of the lottery system, but it will require changes in the way that lotteries are promoted and administered.

Does Running a Lottery Serve the Public Interest?
Scroll to top